Who controls the money?
Updated: October 2026
Overview
How it works
146
Countries and currency areas are exploring a CBDC. They represent over 98% of the global economy (Atlantic Council, May 2026).
98.5 %
of eNaira wallets in Nigeria remained unused in a typical week (IMF 2023).
17.5 million
times the purchase of a flight ticket was denied in China in 2018, due to entries on blacklists.
73.4 %
of voters enshrined the supply of cash in the Swiss Constitution on 8 March 2026.
Three types of money
Money is an agreement about value. What matters is who sets the rules of this agreement, who is allowed to change them, and who can see what you spend it on.
The spectrum of control
The further to the right, the more insight and intervention by a central authority.
Cash
Coins and notes are direct claims against the central bank. If you hold them, you do not need anyone else to pay. A payment leaves no digital trail and works without electricity or a network.
Bank money
The balance in your account is a claim against a commercial bank. The bank manages the account and is legally obliged to check payments and report suspicious activity. Interventions such as account freezes are only possible by official or court order, following defined procedures, deadlines, and legal recourse.
Digital money
Here the paths diverge. Decentralised money like Bitcoin follows rules set in the network that no single entity can change. Central Bank Digital Currency (CBDC) is the opposite: A single entity issues it, manages the register, and sets the rules.
Central and decentralised: the fundamental difference
In a centralised system, all paths lead to one central point. In a decentralised system, this point does not exist.
Centralised vs decentralised
| Question | CBDC | Cash | Bitcoin |
|---|---|---|---|
| Who issues it? | Central bank | Central bank | nobody, fixed protocol |
| Who determines the supply? | Central bank, changeable at any time | Central bank | Code, max 21 million |
| Who sees the payment? | Central bank, depending on the design | nobody | everyone, under a pseudonym |
| Can a payment be blocked? | yes, automatically | no | hardly, without an intermediary |
| Can a balance expire? | technically yes | no | no |
| Does it need electricity and a network? | yes, only limited offline | no | ja |
| Who changes the rules? | Legislator and central bank | Legislator | only broad consensus in the network |
What a CBDC is
CBDC stands for Central Bank Digital Currency: digital money issued directly by the central bank that represents a claim against it, just like cash, only without a physical form.
Two variants
Wholesale CBDC
Only for banks and financial institutions, for settling large payments. The Swiss National Bank is testing this in project Helvetia. Little changes for private individuals.
Retail CBDC
For all citizens, in everyday life via app or card. This is the variant discussed here, such as the digital euro or the Chinese e-CNY.
Why central banks want it
Officially stated: cash is declining, private payment providers and stablecoins are gaining power, payments should be cheaper, faster and crisis-proof, and people without bank accounts should gain access. These arguments are to be taken seriously. What is decisive is what becomes possible in addition.
“The critical difference with a CBDC is that the central bank will have absolute control over the rules and regulations that will determine the use of that expression of central bank liability, and we will have the technology to enforce that.”
Carstens contrasted the statement with cash: with a 100-dollar bill, no one knows who is currently using it. Exactly this property is lost with a CBDC.
The core
Programmable money
Programmable means: conditions can be attached to every payment. A rule in the system decides whether it is executed before the money flows.
A payment with built-in rules
Schematic representation. Which checks a specific system performs is determined by its operator.
With cash, this verification step does not exist. With a bank payment, it exists partially, but involves humans, delays, and legal channels. With programmable central bank money, it runs automatically, in milliseconds, and for everyone at the same time.
What becomes technically possible
| Function | What it means | Does this already exist? |
|---|---|---|
| Expiry date | Credit expires if it is not spent by a deadline. | Yes. In October 2020, Shenzhen distributed 10 million yuan in e-CNY via lottery, valid for one week and only at selected shops. |
| Purpose limitation | Money can only be spent on specific goods or services. | Tested in pilot projects for subsidies and vouchers. |
| Holding limit | No one is allowed to own more than a set amount. | Planned for the digital euro, around 3,000 euros per person were discussed. |
| Negative interest | Balance shrinks automatically to force spending. | Technically easy to implement. Ineffective with cash because it can be withdrawn. |
| Instant blocking | An account or person is excluded from payment transactions with a single click. | Already practised with bank accounts (see account freezes). With CBDC without an intermediary. |
| Geographical restriction | Payments only in a specific region or within a certain time window. | Applied in Chinese voucher pilots with regional restrictions. |
Where the risk lies
From convenience to dependency
In extreme cases, critics speak of digital enslavement: a state in which a central authority determines if, what for, where, and when a person may spend their own money, with no cash as an exit. Whether it reaches this point depends on three conditions: Does cash disappear? Is money linked to identity and behaviour? Are independent controls missing? The more this applies, the more realistic the scenario becomes.
Money, identity, health: the connection
Viewed individually, every system has a logical purpose. The real danger arises where they converge.
Three systems, one intersection
Intersection: payment depends on person and status.
Programmable money can only react to a person if it knows who is paying. This connection is created by digital identity. If further data sources are added, such as health data, tax status, or registry entries, payments can be tied to conditions that have nothing to do with the money itself.
What is already being built
| System | As of October 2026 |
|---|---|
| EU Digital Identity Wallet (eIDAS 2.0) | Every EU member state must offer a digital identity wallet by December 2026. From around December 2027, banks, telecoms, energy, transport, healthcare, and large online platforms must accept it. |
| Swiss e-ID | Narrowly approved on 28 September 2025 with 50.4% in favour. Voluntary and free of charge, available from the end of 2026. |
| European Health Data Space (EHDS) | In effect since March 2025. From 2029, patient summaries and e-prescriptions are to be interchangeable across the EU, with images, lab results, and hospital reports added from 2031. There is a right to opt out of use for research. |
| Digital Euro | The EU Parliament voted 416 to 169 in favour of negotiations on 9 July 2026. Pilot from 2027, issuance earliest in 2029. |
A thought experiment
During the pandemic, access to restaurants, events, or travel was tied to a digital certificate in many countries. With a linked payment system, the same rule could have controlled not just access but also payments, without a controller at the door, automatically, nationwide. Other conceivable rules: payments blocked for outstanding taxes, fuel purchases limited by CO₂ quotas, donations blocked to organisations on a list.
Classification
The potential for danger
In depth
All topics
Not financial advice. General information without guarantee. Crypto assets can lose value up to a total loss.